When to ask (per-product timing)
Last updated: November 17, 2026
Rolling out. Per-product timing is being switched on store by store. Until it’s on for your store, the When to ask tab doesn’t appear under Collect, and every product uses the trigger and delay in your review request settings. If you’d like it sooner, email us.
A cushion is ready to review a week after it arrives. A sofa, a skincare routine or a made-to-order piece may need a month. When to ask lets you set that per product, instead of one delay for your whole store.
Where to find it
Collect → When to ask. The page has three parts:
- Store default: the timing every product uses unless a rule says otherwise. It’s read-only here: it comes from Collect → Emails → Review request → Settings, under Timing. It also shows your estimated delivery time, used when a carrier doesn’t confirm delivery.
- Rules: your timing rules. Click Add rule to create one for a tag or a product type.
- Products: every product, with when we ask for it and where that timing comes from (Product, Tag: …, Type: … or Store default). Search or filter by tag, product type, vendor, status or timing source, then select products to give them their own timing.
While the page shows Preview mode — no emails are sent yet, your rules are saved and shown, but emails still go out on your store-wide timing. If it shows Engine paused, per-product timing is on hold for now; your rules are kept and you can keep editing them.
Setting a rule
A rule covers one of:
- Products with a tag: every product with that Shopify tag, including products that get the tag later
- A product type: every product with that Shopify product type, including future ones
- Individual products: only the products you selected; products you add later use your other rules
Then pick Ask for a review:
- Days after delivery: counts from the day the parcel arrives. If the carrier doesn’t confirm delivery, we use your estimated delivery time.
- Days after shipping: counts from the day it ships, whether or not delivery is confirmed.
- Days after the order: for digital or no-shipping items.
- Never ask: for samples, spare parts or gift cards. A product a Never ask rule stopped isn’t asked about later, even if you remove the tag.
Days can be anything from 0 to 180. The editor previews when the email would go out for example order, ship and delivery dates. Saving shows how many products the change moves and how many planned requests it re-times; large changes (more than 500 products, Never ask on more than 100, or deleting a rule) ask you to confirm. You can have up to 230 rules.
Which rule wins
- A rule for the individual product
- Then a tag rule
- Then a product type rule
- Then your store default
When a product has several tags with rules, Never ask wins; otherwise the rule that asks latest wins. The product list flags those products with Also matches: ….
Tag and product-type rules follow your Shopify catalog. If you, a teammate or another app changes a product’s tags or type, the rule that covers it changes too.
Limits that always apply
Whatever timing you choose, some limits stay in place so a customer is never asked too late or too often:
- Never too late. We don’t ask more than 45 days after delivery (or estimated delivery), or more than 90 days after the order. A request that would fall after that isn’t sent and shows as Order too old to send.
- Not too often. By default a customer gets at most 3 review emails from your store in 60 days, at least 7 days apart, and isn’t asked again about a product they were asked about in the last 12 months. On the Free plan it’s at most 1 email per customer every 30 days.
- Combined when due together. Products due at the same time go into one email, up to 4, highest price first; the rest wait for the next send window.
- Send window and consent. Emails still go out in the customer’s send window, and everyone the skip rules cover (unsubscribed, suppressed, already reviewed, and so on) is still skipped.
- No late catch-up. If sending was paused for more than a day, requests that came due during the pause aren’t sent late; they show as Order too old to send.
Per-product timing doesn’t run while Klaviyo sends your review requests. BetterReviews doesn’t send reminders; if you want them, add them to your Klaviyo flow.
Managing rules from your own tools
The same rules are available through the Ask Rules API. For an AI agent that manages timing, create a Timing rules only key in Settings → Integrations → API access: it can read and change timing rules and nothing else, so it never sees reviews or customer data.
Book a demo