How to Switch from Judge.me to BetterReviews
Thinking about switching from Judge.me? What the migration looks like — OAuth connection, what you keep, common fears, and the cutover sequence.
What it costs
Judge.me has a free tier and a paid tier at $15/mo (Awesome), with add-ons that push effective spend toward $50/mo for stores running a serious review program. BetterReviews (Better plan) is $149/mo: unlimited orders, reviews, and review request emails, with 1,000 AI credits included every month (1 per AI-guided review).
Our Free plan matches Judge.me’s free tier on price. The AI conversation and white-glove migration start at $49 on the Good plan (150 a month); Better at $149 adds 1,000 a month and a dedicated CSM. Being straight about that matters more than a savings table. Here is what Better adds.
Someone runs it for you. On every paid plan we do the migration for you. On Better and Studio we also get the widget set up on your theme, and read your dashboard once a month to tell you what your reviews are actually saying. Same CSM every time. No ticket queue, no tier-one script.
Reviews detailed enough to put in marketing. Judge.me collects through a form. BetterReviews collects through a short conversation that asks follow-up questions. On Missouri Star Quilt Company, a co-founder’s store and the first store this was built for, the switch took median review length from 12 words to 26, and the share of reviews detailed enough to use in marketing went from 9% to 30%.
This page is for stores that have outgrown short, form-shaped reviews — whether you are on Judge.me’s free plan or the $15 Awesome plan.
The Free plan costs nothing and has no time limit, so a long switch costs you nothing. Import your reviews yourself, run the widget on them, send review requests on the classic form, and take as long as you need. Billing starts only if and when you subscribe; the done-for-you migration is included on every paid plan.
Common fears addressed
”I’m on the free plan. Why pay $49/mo or more?”
Because at some point the constraint stops being how many reviews you have and starts being what they say. If basic reviews still do the job for your store, the free plan is a reasonable place to stay.
The merchants who switch usually do so because their reviews are short (“great product!”), photo-light, and don’t tell shoppers anything that helps them buy. BetterReviews’ chat draws out 100+ word reviews with specifics — use case, comparison with alternatives, and photos — by asking follow-up questions a form can’t.
”Do I need Judge.me’s paid plan to migrate?”
No. When you connect Judge.me, BetterReviews pulls your full review history through Judge.me’s API, on Judge.me’s free plan or Awesome alike. There is no need to upgrade Judge.me to migrate.
What Awesome adds is live sync afterwards: Judge.me’s webhooks are only on Awesome, so on Awesome new Judge.me reviews reach BetterReviews within a minute. On Judge.me’s free plan, click Sync Reviews in BetterReviews to pull reviews that came in after the import. That only matters if you keep collecting on Judge.me for a while after you connect.
”Will Judge.me leave code in my theme?”
This is a known issue. Judge.me has been reported to leave widget snippets behind in theme files after uninstall. The migration guide step 4 covers cleanup; budget 15 minutes to grep your theme for judgeme references and remove them. BetterReviews won’t load over Judge.me’s leftover code, but you may have residual layout issues until you scrub the old snippets.
”I use Judge.me Loyalty / Rewards”
Judge.me Loyalty is a separate product from Reviews — if you’re keeping Loyalty, you don’t have to uninstall the whole Judge.me suite. Just remove the Reviews extension. BetterReviews focuses on reviews; pick a separate loyalty app (Smile.io, Yotpo Loyalty) for that workflow.
”Will I lose my reviews?”
No. Judge.me supports both direct OAuth import and CSV export, and on every paid plan a person on our team watches the import through (on Free you run it yourself): original dates, star ratings, text, photos, and product associations all come across, plus verified buyer status when present. Photos are copied onto BetterReviews storage. Videos and merchant replies don’t come across through the connection, because Judge.me’s API doesn’t provide them; replies can be brought over with a CSV import. We send you a count-match report per product, reviews in on Judge.me against reviews out on BetterReviews, so you can see nothing went missing. Judge.me reviews that aren’t tied to a product are imported too and kept in your dashboard; they aren’t shown on any product page or on the Store reviews page.
What you keep, what changes
You keep:
- All your existing reviews with original dates, ratings, text and photos
- Verified-buyer badges (when present in Judge.me’s export)
- Rich snippets for SEO — Google re-indexes within 2-4 weeks
You change:
- Widget layout. BetterReviews ships our own widget — you can customize colors, layout, and copy in the dashboard.
- Floating reviews tab. If you used Judge.me’s floating reviews tab, turn on ours — it’s on every plan, and shows your product reviews, plus a Store reviews tab when you have store reviews. See Floating reviews tab.
- Collection mechanism. Judge.me’s review request emails get replaced with BetterReviews’ AI chat conversations (on Good and Better; Free uses the classic review form after 50 AI credits to try). The chat draws out longer, more specific reviews than a form. If you send Judge.me requests through Klaviyo, you can keep sending ours from your Klaviyo flow.
- Q&A. Shoppers ask questions from the Q&A block on your product pages, and you answer them in BetterReviews under Reviews → Questions, on every plan. Only you answer; there are no shopper-to-shopper or AI answers. To keep questions you already have, import them as a CSV — see Importing Q&A.
- Plan structure. A Free plan, then flat Good ($49/mo) and Better ($149/mo) plans instead of a base tier plus add-ons. Orders, reviews, and review request emails are unlimited on every plan; Good adds the AI conversation with 150 AI credits a month (1 per AI-guided review), and Better includes 1,000.
You lose:
- Any Judge.me-specific integrations (Privy, etc.) — BetterReviews has its own integration set, including a native Klaviyo integration.
- Review videos and merchant replies (Judge.me’s API doesn’t provide them — bring replies over via CSV).
Before-you-switch checklist
- Check the reviews you have now. Pull your last 50 and count how many say something a shopper could act on. That number is the reason to switch or not.
- Export your reviews from Judge.me as a backup. Settings > Export Reviews.
- Audit your theme for leftover Judge.me snippets. Plan 15 minutes for cleanup after uninstall.
- Document your current setup. Screenshot widget placement, badge displays, and any custom CSS.
- Plan Loyalty migration separately if you use Judge.me Loyalty.
The migration process
1. Install BetterReviews, connect via OAuth
Install BetterReviews from the Shopify App Store. Onboarding step 1 (/onboarding/connect) has a “Connect Judge.me” card that routes you through OAuth — Judge.me redirects back to BetterReviews and your full review history is imported in the background.
This works on any Judge.me plan. On Awesome, new Judge.me reviews keep syncing by webhook; on Judge.me’s free plan, use Sync Reviews to pull anything that arrives after the import.
2. Add BetterReviews to your theme
Onboarding step 3 (/onboarding/test-product, after Connect and Your look) lets our team swap your widget on a single product and validate end-to-end before you commit to a full cutover. About one business day.
3. Keep new collection off until cutover
Don’t enable BetterReviews collection while Judge.me is still collecting. Run a single product on BetterReviews first, validate it, and only then flip collection at the /cutover surface. This avoids dual-sending review requests to your customers.
When you’re ready, the cutover surface flips collection_enabled and digest_enabled atomically. Before that, BetterReviews stays in observe-only mode on the imported library.
4. Verify your Google stars, then remove Judge.me
We run your product pages through Google’s own testing tools until the stars read from BetterReviews. After that check passes, and not before, uninstall the Judge.me Reviews extension. If you’re keeping Judge.me Loyalty, only remove Reviews. Grep your theme files for judgeme references and remove any leftover snippets: Judge.me is reported to leave code behind on uninstall.
Note: The BetterReviews team handles the import and assists with widget setup. On every paid plan the migration is a handoff, not a DIY project. On Free you import your reviews yourself.
Auto-moderation and your imported reviews
Imported reviews keep the status they had in Judge.me (approved stays approved; pending stays pending). They are not put through BetterReviews’ auto-moderation preset — even if you later switch from Manual to a non-manual preset, the retroactive re-scoring only touches reviews collected through BetterReviews’ AI chat or public form. Imported pending reviews stay in your queue until you approve or reject them by hand. A review you reject stays rejected even if Judge.me sends it again, and approvals you make normally stick too.
Related
- BetterReviews vs Judge.me — full feature and pricing comparison
- Yotpo vs Judge.me — how Judge.me compares to the enterprise option
- Loox vs Judge.me — visual reviews vs free reviews
If you want the fundamentals first, start with the complete guide to Shopify reviews.
Ready to switch from Judge.me?
Free plan, no card. Upgrade when you want more AI-guided reviews. Cancel anytime.
Book a demo